Charlotte and Feodora: A troubled mother-daughter relationship in Imperial Germany by John van der Kiste Book Review




Princess Charlotte of Prussia was born as the daughter of Victoria, Princess Royal and Frederick III, German Emperor on 24 July 1860 in Potsdam. She married her second cousin, the future Duke of Saxe-Meiningen, Prince Bernhard. From this marriage, a single daughter was born on 12 May 1879, who was the first great-grandchild of Queen Victoria. This child was Feodora.

FeodoraSaMeiReuCharlotte_von_Preussen_1883

Feodora and Charlotte had a difficult relationship with Feodora favouring her maternal grandmother, Victoria, Princess Royal.

Both mother and daughter probably suffered from porphyria, inherited from George III of the United Kingdom. They both suffered from a lifetime of ill-health. Porphyria can cause abdominal pain, with vomiting, hypertension and tachycardia. It can lead to muscle weakness, a paralysis of all four limbs, seizures, coma and can also cause anxiety, hallucinations, psychosis and confusion.

I really enjoyed reading about these two women and learning more about them. John Van Der Kiste writes really well, and there’s a good flow in the book. It also includes a fair bit of personal correspondence, which is a really nice touch.

Charlotte was unhappy with Feodora’s choice of husband, Prince Heinrich XXX Reuss. Feodora wanted to have children of her own, but this proved difficult. Charlotte could have done without ‘the damned brood’. Feodora’s health deteriorated rather quickly. She suffered longer periods of ill-health, for example from September 1899 to March 1900. She never gave up on having a child and visited several private clinics, and she even underwent an attempt at artificial insemination. Apparently, the operation and a subsequent one almost cost her her life.

Charlotte died on 1 October 1919, less than a year after the First World War forced her husband´s abdication. She died of a heart attack at the age of 59.

Feodora disappears from the world for a while. Not much is known of the time between her mother’s death and her husband’s death on 22 March 1939. By the time of his death, she was hospitalised in the Sanitorium Buchwald-Hohenwiese. It must have been a lonely time for her. By the end of the Second World War Feodora’s mind was made up and the book ends with this sudden line. ‘and put her head in a gas oven’. Feodora committed suicide on 26 August 1945. Her death went unnoticed in the papers.

Both women had quite sad life, and this book brings them alive, although not always in a positive light. That is just a part of who these women were, and both handled their hardships in a different way. I do highly recommend this book if you’re interested in these two overshadowed women. (UK & US)






About Moniek 1269 Articles
My name is Moniek and I am from the Netherlands. I began this website in 2013 because I wanted to share these women's amazing stories.

1 Comment

  1. I have just started getting interested in the history of royals by watching Victoria on my Local PBS channel. I watched seasons two and three, but did not get to watch season one.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.